Nassau County’s proposed legislation might dramatically alter the interaction between police and the public, raising critical questions about safety and civil rights.
Key Takeaways
- Nassau County proposes to make it illegal to stand within 15 feet of police during emergencies.
- Violations could result in a misdemeanor, fines, or jail time.
- The measure is intended to protect first responders from harassment.
- Critics argue it may infringe on constitutional freedoms and transparency.
- Similar measures in other states were previously blocked for constitutional concerns.
Nassau County Considers New Buffer Law
Nassau County, New York, is pushing forward with a legislative proposal aiming to establish a 15-foot buffer zone surrounding police officers and first responders during emergencies. This measure has garnered bipartisan support in the wake of rising concerns over safety and interference during emergency operations. Violating this proposed law could result in a misdemeanor charge, fines up to $1,000, and even a year of jail time.
This proposal aims to safeguard officers and first responders from potential threats and crowd-induced distractions during their critical duties. Proponents argue that the legislation offers necessary support for frontline workers. Legislator John Ferretti remarked, “It is important that first responders are not obstructed during emergency situations and that our frontline heroes are allowed to engage in the lifesaving actions they are trained to perform without distractions.”
New York's Nassau County seeks to ban standing within 15 feet of cops under bill panned as unconstitutional https://t.co/KaJci2BJS8
— Fox News Politics (@foxnewspolitics) April 23, 2025
Concerns Over Constitutional Rights
Despite bipartisan support, criticism has surfaced from civil liberties groups like the New York Civil Liberties Union, who express concerns about potential violations of constitutional rights. Critics warn that the measure could inhibit the public’s ability to record and monitor police activity—a critical part of keeping public servants accountable.
In similar cases, buffer zone laws in states like Louisiana and Indiana have been challenged and subsequently blocked by federal judges. These laws were found unconstitutional due to their vagueness and potential for arbitrary enforcement. This raises questions about how Nassau County’s proposed buffer zone will fare against legal scrutiny.
Lessons from Other States
Federal district courts have dealt previously with laws similar to Nassau County’s proposal. Louisiana’s law, which created a 25-foot buffer, was struck down due to its lack of clarity and failure to align with First Amendment protections. Judges highlighted the risk of discriminatory enforcement, which could arbitrarily restrict journalists’ and citizens’ rights to record public servants.
Democrat legislator Seth Koslow advocates that such measures are vital, commenting, “Our cops and first responders shouldn’t have to fight crowds while they’re saving lives. This bill gives them the authority to keep chaos out and do their jobs without interference. It’s backed by both parties — because protecting those who protect us shouldn’t be political.”
With both support and opposition laid bare, the future of Nassau County’s proposed buffer zone law seems uncertain. Its efficacy and legality will likely face challenges in courts, reflecting a broader national debate on finding the balance between security and civil liberties.
Sources
- New York’s Nassau County seeks to ban standing within 15 feet of cops under bill panned as unconstitutional
- Nassau County wants to make it illegal to stand within 15 feet of cops — but critics say ‘buffer zone’ is unconstitutional
- When police say ‘stand back,’ these states say how far
- Federal district court blocks enforcement of Louisiana police ‘buffer zone’ law
