A UK pharmacist warns against popular supplements, suggesting they may be doing more harm than good.
At a Glance
- Amina Khan, a UK pharmacist, advises against gummy vitamins due to high sugar content
- General multivitamins are considered ineffective for most adults
- Khan recommends targeted supplements for specific health concerns
- Balanced diet is preferred over multivitamins for nutrient intake
Gummy Vitamins: A Sweet Deception?
Amina Khan, a respected UK pharmacist and founder of The Pharmacist Beauty, has raised concerns about the effectiveness and potential risks of certain dietary supplements. In particular, she warns against the use of gummy vitamins, which have gained popularity in recent years. Despite their appealing taste and convenience, Khan argues that these supplements may not be the best choice for health-conscious individuals.
“These are basically just a sugar pill — you might as well go have a sweet,” Khan states bluntly.
The primary issue with gummy vitamins is their high sugar content, often containing 3 to 5 grams of sugar per gummy. This added sugar not only contradicts the health-conscious intentions of most supplement users but can also contribute to dental problems and other health issues if consumed regularly. Moreover, the sugar content in gummies can make it easy to overconsume them, potentially leading to mineral toxicity.
Nutrient Deficiency in Gummy Form
Another significant drawback of gummy vitamins is their lower nutrient content compared to traditional multivitamin capsules or tablets. The manufacturing process and the need to make them palatable often result in fewer vitamins and minerals being included. This means that consumers may not be getting the full spectrum of nutrients they believe they are.
For adults, Khan recommends sticking to traditional capsules or tablets. These forms typically offer a more comprehensive and potent nutrient profile without the added sugars. For children who may have difficulty swallowing pills, Khan suggests exploring liquid or spray supplements as a healthier alternative to gummies.
The Multivitamin Myth
Khan’s critique extends beyond gummy vitamins to general multivitamins as well. She echoes the sentiments of some researchers who consider these supplements a waste of money for most adults. Despite their widespread use, there is no substantial evidence that general multivitamins reduce the risk of heart disease, cancer, or premature death in healthy individuals.
The primary issue with general multivitamins is that they often contain low doses of various nutrients, which may not be sufficient to have a meaningful impact on health. Khan advises that a balanced diet is generally the best approach for obtaining necessary nutrients, rather than relying on a multivitamin supplement.
Exceptions and Targeted Approaches
While Khan is critical of general multivitamin use, she acknowledges that there are exceptions. Pregnant women and individuals with diagnosed nutrient deficiencies may benefit from multivitamin supplementation under medical supervision. However, for the majority of adults, a more targeted approach to supplementation is recommended.
Khan is particularly skeptical of multivitamins marketed for improving hair, skin, and nails. These products have gained popularity through social media influence, but their effectiveness is questionable. Instead of these broad-spectrum supplements, Khan suggests using “solution-focused supplements” that target specific health concerns. This approach allows for a more precise and potentially more effective method of addressing individual health needs.
Making Informed Choices
The insights provided by Amina Khan serve as a reminder of the importance of critical thinking when it comes to dietary supplements. While supplements can play a role in maintaining health, they are not a one-size-fits-all solution. Consumers are encouraged to consult with healthcare professionals, prioritize a balanced diet, and consider targeted supplements only when necessary for specific health goals.
As the supplement industry continues to grow and evolve, it’s crucial for individuals to stay informed and make choices based on scientific evidence rather than marketing hype. By following expert advice like Khan’s, consumers can navigate the complex world of dietary supplements more effectively, ensuring that their health choices are both beneficial and cost-effective.
Sources:
I’m a pharmacist and would never take these 3 supplements — beware a viral social media trend
